Ranking Every Kevin Costner Baseball Movie
No actor is more closely linked with baseball movies than Kevin Costner. Over the years, he’s become almost synonymous with the genre — and with sports films in general. It’s not just about the number of titles he’s been in; it’s also about the quality. Many of the most beloved sports films star Costner in central roles, helping solidify his legacy in this space.
There’s always been a debate among fans about which genre suits him best: westerns or sports films. Both have been significant in shaping his career. While westerns showcase his rugged charisma, there’s something about the emotional resonance of sports — especially baseball — that seems to bring out his most iconic performances. In the end, sports might just narrowly win out.
Over his career, Costner has starred in five baseball movies, each offering something unique. Interestingly, he rarely plays the same kind of character twice — ranging from pitcher to catcher to someone simply caught up in the spirit of the game. The range makes this an especially fascinating set of films.
5. Chasing Dreams (1982)
If Chasing Dreams doesn’t ring a bell, you’re not alone. This early ’80s indie project flew well under the radar, and even fans of Costner might have missed it. Still, it holds a special place in his filmography.
This was just the second film role of Costner’s career, following Sizzle Beach, U.S.A. He plays the older brother of the film’s main character, a teenager living on a farm who discovers a talent for baseball.
While Costner’s role is small, the movie feels like an omen — setting the stage for his future as Hollywood’s go-to baseball guy.
4. The Upside of Anger (2005)
Though not strictly a baseball movie, The Upside of Anger features Costner as a former pro ballplayer, adding another layer to his connection with the sport.
This romantic dramedy focuses on Terry (Joan Allen), a woman struggling with abandonment after her husband leaves. She finds an unexpected relationship with Denny (Costner), a retired baseball star turned radio host with a penchant for drinking.
Despite baseball playing only a minor role in the plot, Costner brings real weight to the character. Some believe Denny is loosely inspired by former Detroit Tigers pitcher Denny McLain — a connection made more interesting given Costner would play a Tigers pitcher just a few years earlier.
The film received strong reviews, especially for the chemistry between Costner and Allen, and boasts a stellar supporting cast, including Keri Russell and Evan Rachel Wood.
3. For Love of the Game (1999)
Directed by horror legend Sam Raimi, For Love of the Game is one of the most underappreciated entries in Costner’s baseball lineup. It didn’t receive the same acclaim as his other classics, but it still delivers an emotionally layered story.
Costner plays Billy Chapel, a veteran pitcher for the Detroit Tigers who is contemplating retirement. The movie unfolds as he attempts to pitch a perfect game at Yankee Stadium, all while reflecting on a complicated relationship with his ex (played by Kelly Preston).
Though the romantic storyline drags at times, the baseball sequences are gripping, and Costner’s dynamic with catcher John C. Reilly is a highlight. Legendary broadcaster Vin Scully provides commentary, adding an extra layer of authenticity.
While it didn’t hit a home run with critics — it sits at 47% on Rotten Tomatoes — it remains a compelling blend of sports drama and personal reflection.
2. Field of Dreams (1989)
For many fans, Field of Dreams isn’t just a great baseball movie — it’s a spiritual experience. Costner plays Ray Kinsella, an Iowa farmer who hears a mysterious voice urging him to build a baseball field in the middle of his cornfield.
When he does, ghosts of iconic players, including Shoeless Joe Jackson, begin to appear. But at its heart, the story is about family, legacy, and reconciling with the past — especially between fathers and sons.
Costner doesn’t play a ballplayer this time, but his role is one of his most heartfelt. The film became a pop culture phenomenon, leading to real-life MLB games being played at a replica field in Iowa.
Field of Dreams was a box office success, earned three Oscar nominations (including Best Picture), and was later added to the National Film Registry for its cultural significance.
1. Bull Durham (1988)
Widely regarded as not just Kevin Costner’s best baseball movie, but possibly the best baseball movie ever made, Bull Durham is a true classic.
Costner stars as “Crash” Davis, a seasoned minor league catcher brought in to mentor a talented but immature young pitcher (Tim Robbins). Both men get entangled with Annie Savoy (Susan Sarandon), a devoted fan who “chooses” a player to be with each season.
The film’s focus on the minor leagues gives it a grounded, relatable feel. Costner delivers arguably his finest performance here — charming, wise, and full of passion for the game.
Bull Durham received near-universal acclaim, holds a 97% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, and was named the greatest sports film of all time by Sports Illustrated. Many consider it the peak of Costner’s film career — not just in sports, but across all genres.
Final Thoughts:
Kevin Costner’s baseball films span decades, styles, and roles — but they all share one thing: a deep love for the game. Whether he’s on the field or watching from the sidelines, he brings a level of sincerity and reverence that few actors can match. His legacy in baseball movies isn’t just about playing the part — it’s about honoring what the sport represents.
