One Major Factor That Made Tombstone Outshine Kevin Costner’s Wyatt Earp Movie
One Key Element That Made Tombstone Outshine Kevin Costner’s Wyatt Earp
Kurt Russell’s 1993 Western, Tombstone, triumphed over Kevin Costner’s Wyatt Earp, released a year later, for one significant reason. Tombstone is widely regarded as one of the best Westerns of the 1990s, revitalizing the genre upon its release. In contrast, Costner’s film, which aimed for more historical accuracy while covering the same events, struggled at the box office, earning $56 million compared to Tombstone‘s $73 million.
Both films depict the legendary lawman and the iconic shootout at the O.K. Corral, but Wyatt Earp faced criticism for its lengthy three-hour runtime, which slowed the pacing and made it less engaging than Tombstone‘s action-packed narrative. However, there was one standout element that ensured Tombstone‘s box office success: Val Kilmer’s unforgettable performance as Doc Holliday.
Val Kilmer’s Performance Seals Tombstone’s Success Over Wyatt Earp
Val Kilmer’s charismatic portrayal of Doc Holliday was a crucial factor in Tombstone’s success, eclipsing Dennis Quaid’s interpretation in Wyatt Earp. Both actors captured the essence of the sickly yet formidable gunslinger, showcasing his calm demeanor and darker impulses as he assisted his friends in their vendetta against the Cowboys. However, Quaid’s performance felt somewhat stiff and traditional, making it harder for audiences to connect with his character.
In contrast, Kilmer brought a captivating charm and fluidity to his role, delivering lines that have become iconic. His version of Doc Holliday is not only witty and wise but also unpredictable and deeply weary, creating moments that are both poignant and striking. Kilmer’s interactions with Russell’s Wyatt Earp added depth to the narrative, solidifying Tombstone as the cult classic it remains today.
